They have been successful in raising the dust about patriotism [ or is it nationalism ] and sending the real issue behind the curtain of dust so created. Whose is best? Left's "Salaam Lal Zenda" they shouted is better, RSS said 'Saffron is the colour of patriotism.' Muslim were always with green so unfurled green.
I asked many a learned friend, as I was extremely confused by the definition of the nation itself. None could come forward to help. The confusion is so omnipresent, that more the people more the confusion! As for myself, I found none. Is it the map delineated by arbitrary lines drawn on the paper? Is it the geography or is its topography? Is it its people, their culture, their language what exactly it is!
Nationalism comes later, patriotism even later, much later. Because one has to be sure when he says 'This is my nation' when everything about it is just arbitrary! And only after one defines nation to which he belongs to, the word patriotism comes into being because it means loyalty, unbounded love, a deep sense of belonging to the Nation, a concept he nurtures to his cores!
Recently I had been to, two international borders of India. Indo China And Indo Bangla Desh.
The border between India and China passes through Bum La Pass in Tawang, which was fiercely fought in the Indo China war of 1962. We were told by a very authentic source, that there is no border as such. Chinese and Indian soldiers stand in front of each other and if one retreats or advances in others territory the border changes! So the vigilance has to be 24 *7 *365! One bad step on part of the soldier on the duty, India becomes smaller by a few feet! India's border, in short, is that volatile! So are those few feet India, The nation?
On the contrary Indo Bangla Desh border the post we visited at Tamabil, was having barricades, definite precautionary boards about the customs, the boundaries, surprisingly above all, friendly sentries on either side. Nonetheless, Indo Bangla border at many places is equally porous and arbitrary at times passing through the mid-river!
The point is, the nation defined by its borders, which at most of the times simply are arbitrary, how one can define!
Once while going to Keukenhof in the Netherlands from Belgium I was eagerly waiting for such a scenario of well-dressed sentries, the barricades painted in yellow and black, a gate with an immigration personal vicariously eager to pounce on me for my passport. Nothing of the sort happened! Not even a board welcoming you to 'Netherlands.' I asked my son in law, ' If such is the case, how do you know that we have crossed the border ?' Smilingly he replied, 'By number plates on the vehicles and traffic signs on the highways! The language changes.'
If the language then defines the nation where should we put the multilingual states, [and practically all are.] like China which has more than 100 local languages! Switzerland speaks in 4 languages, even in America, in southern parts, Spanish is spoken more than English! So is it Spain or part of America the nation that speaks Spanish? And us The Indians? Oh less said the better. It's said and accepted too, that language changes every twelve miles! Oh, how many nations within a nation we would have then? I am exhausted just at the thought!
The culture? The Religion? Useless yardsticks again. Give and take a few variations Europe practically has one religion but the nations are different. The countries like Pakistan, UAE have same religion but are they cohesive enough to be called a nation, really? So religion takes a retreat. The culture within the groups, even apparently similar, varies so much in the rituals they practice that sometimes it would be ironic to call them one group, to call them a nation would be a distant dream!
I asked many a learned friend, as I was extremely confused by the definition of the nation itself. None could come forward to help. The confusion is so omnipresent, that more the people more the confusion! As for myself, I found none. Is it the map delineated by arbitrary lines drawn on the paper? Is it the geography or is its topography? Is it its people, their culture, their language what exactly it is!
Nationalism comes later, patriotism even later, much later. Because one has to be sure when he says 'This is my nation' when everything about it is just arbitrary! And only after one defines nation to which he belongs to, the word patriotism comes into being because it means loyalty, unbounded love, a deep sense of belonging to the Nation, a concept he nurtures to his cores!
Recently I had been to, two international borders of India. Indo China And Indo Bangla Desh.
The border between India and China passes through Bum La Pass in Tawang, which was fiercely fought in the Indo China war of 1962. We were told by a very authentic source, that there is no border as such. Chinese and Indian soldiers stand in front of each other and if one retreats or advances in others territory the border changes! So the vigilance has to be 24 *7 *365! One bad step on part of the soldier on the duty, India becomes smaller by a few feet! India's border, in short, is that volatile! So are those few feet India, The nation?
On the contrary Indo Bangla Desh border the post we visited at Tamabil, was having barricades, definite precautionary boards about the customs, the boundaries, surprisingly above all, friendly sentries on either side. Nonetheless, Indo Bangla border at many places is equally porous and arbitrary at times passing through the mid-river!
The point is, the nation defined by its borders, which at most of the times simply are arbitrary, how one can define!
Once while going to Keukenhof in the Netherlands from Belgium I was eagerly waiting for such a scenario of well-dressed sentries, the barricades painted in yellow and black, a gate with an immigration personal vicariously eager to pounce on me for my passport. Nothing of the sort happened! Not even a board welcoming you to 'Netherlands.' I asked my son in law, ' If such is the case, how do you know that we have crossed the border ?' Smilingly he replied, 'By number plates on the vehicles and traffic signs on the highways! The language changes.'
If the language then defines the nation where should we put the multilingual states, [and practically all are.] like China which has more than 100 local languages! Switzerland speaks in 4 languages, even in America, in southern parts, Spanish is spoken more than English! So is it Spain or part of America the nation that speaks Spanish? And us The Indians? Oh less said the better. It's said and accepted too, that language changes every twelve miles! Oh, how many nations within a nation we would have then? I am exhausted just at the thought!
The culture? The Religion? Useless yardsticks again. Give and take a few variations Europe practically has one religion but the nations are different. The countries like Pakistan, UAE have same religion but are they cohesive enough to be called a nation, really? So religion takes a retreat. The culture within the groups, even apparently similar, varies so much in the rituals they practice that sometimes it would be ironic to call them one group, to call them a nation would be a distant dream!
Then what it is ?!
In my opinion, its THE Feeling which shows empathy to a fellow being even though he/she is remotely related to you in all aspects and respects in the distant corner of the world far away from your land, it's the storm of emotions which engulfs you giving goose pimples when the tricolour is unfurled in any part of the world, reminding you the flavours of your soil, its that bond when your eyes get wet when you know that, that one unknown soldier laid his life for you to enjoy your freedom of speech.
Why you want the definition of a nation on a constitutional level, it's a gut feeling that tells you to do what's correct and it's definitely not in, to break what is so beautiful!