Sunday, 2 June 2019

Reservation: A step to social unrest ?


It would be almost 5 decades since I opted for Medicine, to be precise in June 1970. Though I was schooled in so-called Brahmanical school, the caste was never asked and was never a taboo. Many of my friends[ Whose castes I came to know much, much later in life] came to our home to play and then stayed over many times to have grub made by my mother. My mother too never hesitated to eat the food made by Muslim cooks even in those days. Because it was never thought in that direction ever.
I realized it for the first time that there exists something like ‘Caste System’ when I entered the Medical school. It so happened that, I saw somebody, who never scored good marks, [good enough to be in the merit], in the school and/or junior college taking admission along with me in the same queue. I was not flabbergasted or something that melodramatic but was curious. On exploring the details, I came to know that, He had secured the admission through the quota system. ‘Reservation’ in today’s parlance. My encounter with the ‘Caste system’ for the first time.
I do not want to cast any aspersions on anybody’s credentials but the group stood out like a sore thumb, as most of them came from the interiors, the diction while answering in the orals gave them away immediately. Again I would like to ascertain here, and without any bias whatsoever on my part, not their fault, because for want of the exposure they lacked the polish of the city-bred. The government too was discriminating. Rather than allotting them the rooms in general hostels, they had separate hostel making it amply clear their roots and origins. Like calling the ‘Untouchable’ ‘Harijans’
I got the first jolt when in spite of getting more than 65% of marks in Final MBBS I was not good enough to secure a seat in the Post Graduation course. And to my surprise, many from ‘the group’ just walked away with the premier seats though they had much, much fewer marks than me! It hurt, it did hurt because I too had not come from the wealthy family and was having an absolutely lower-middle-class existence. The upbringing was so spineless that there was no question of fighting the system!
I shifted to Mumbai for higher education and it turned out to be a blessing in disguise. Mumbai is such a big cauldron of variety of social layers that everything just melts in it. Your caste just does not matter. For everybody! So wives of the downtrodden, once get used to Mumbai potpourri, do not wish to return to their native villages for fear of losing the freedom from the clutches of the system that’s still prevalent and being practised mercilessly back home!
My PG studentship was uneventful because it used to be a big family, for every department. Seniors taking good care of the juniors and HODs keen in teaching us and guiding in difficult situations. Workload, always loaded!
The chasm was not apparent then, amongst the residents, at least caste wise! The one that I did not experience in student days, started showing its fangs when the Mandal Commission report was implemented. As the reservation went from 33% to around 50% suddenly, the resentment in the open merit candidates became palpable. When I was unit head, in casual conversations too, the boys had started taking their reservations for granted. It was turning very painful for me because in my opinion in any highly skilled  professions like Medicine and/or Engineering the only thing that must matter, is Merit! I also abhor the brats of wealthy parents who buy their seats in the auction!
The second generation of the reserved category is more aggressive. With the parents on the higher posts, mostly in the government, it enjoys all the luxuries and riches and is blatantly aware of their ‘Rights’ of reservation! When Open category student has to struggle at every step in LIFE, it’s like Red carpet treatment for Category students from A. Admissions. to 2. PG courses to 3. Government Jobs to 4. Promotions. Everything is as if offered on the platter and the worst thing is ‘They are aware of it!’
I had to take one particular candidate who was blacklisted in the previous interviews, only because that year the seat was reserved for his category! In such situations I did fear the backlash, so always opted for the soft options, keeping patient care last on the agenda! The worst was to come. One dejected resident who did not get the registrar’s post went ahead and lodged a complaint against the selected resident under atrocity act because he belonged to the higher caste! Entire management had extremely tough time to handle the situation!
I do feel sorry for the resident who lost her life, but this is the tip of the iceberg. There does not seem to be an end to the political appeasement on the government’s part.[ Dhangars, Patels, Jats in the waiting] It is simply sacrificing merit on the altar of caste. In certain branches If there is not going to be any post for the Open category, which is the most deserving one, merit wise, then out of frustration, these type of skirmishes amongst the residents are going to increase. Is it the beginning of Social Unrest?